MIG (Metal Inert Gas) welding and Arc welding (also known as Stick welding) are two of the most widely used welding techniques, each with its own unique advantages and disadvantages. When it comes to weld strength, the choice between these two methods depends on various factors, including the type of metal being welded, the thickness of the metal, the desired weld strength, and the welding conditions.
Metal Thickness and Weld Penetration
MIG welding is generally better suited for thinner metals, as it creates a clean and strong joint. The continuous wire feed in MIG welding allows for longer welds and less downtime for changing electrodes. However, MIG welding requires a clean workpiece, as any dirt or rust can affect the quality of the weld.
On the other hand, Arc welding is better for thicker metals, as it can penetrate deeper into the material. This is due to the flux-coated electrodes used in Arc welding, which create a hotter and more focused arc, resulting in better penetration. The deeper penetration of Arc welding can lead to stronger welds, particularly for heavy fabrication tasks such as welding 1-inch thick plates.
Weld Strength and Metallurgical Considerations
Image source: Mig weld example
When it comes to weld strength, Arc welding is generally considered stronger than MIG welding when done correctly. This is because the flux-coated electrodes used in Arc welding create a stronger joint than the shielding gas used in MIG welding. The flux coating helps to remove impurities and create a more stable arc, leading to a higher-quality weld.
However, it’s important to note that the type of metal being welded can also play a significant role in weld strength. For example, 7018 stick welding is often considered stronger than MIG welding for heavy fabrication tasks, as the flux-coated electrodes can better handle the thicker materials.
Additionally, the shielding gas used in MIG welding can also impact weld strength. By using a shielding gas with a higher percentage of CO2, the arc becomes hotter and can achieve better penetration, resulting in stronger welds.
Welding Conditions and Versatility
Arc welding is more versatile than MIG welding, as it can be used in windy conditions or anywhere that the MIG setup’s shielding gas would be compromised. This is because the flux-coated electrodes in Arc welding create their own shielding, making the process less sensitive to external factors.
On the other hand, MIG welding is better suited for welding in tight corners or obtuse angles, as the nozzle can be changed to fit the angle of the weld. This can be particularly useful in confined spaces or when working on complex fabrication projects.
Consumables and Cost Considerations
MIG welding generally requires more consumables, such as the continuously feeding wire and shielding gas, which can make it more expensive than Arc welding. Arc welding, on the other hand, has fewer consumables, such as the flux-coated electrodes, and requires less downtime for changing out electrodes, making it a more cost-effective option in some cases.
Skill and Technique Considerations
Ultimately, the skill and technique of the welder play a crucial role in the strength and quality of the weld, regardless of the welding method used. Both MIG and Arc welding require proper training and practice to achieve optimal results. Factors such as weld preparation, joint design, and post-weld treatment can all impact the final weld strength.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the choice between MIG welding and Arc welding for achieving the desired weld strength depends on a variety of factors, including the type of metal, the thickness of the material, the welding conditions, and the specific application. While Arc welding is generally considered stronger than MIG welding, both methods can produce high-quality welds when executed properly by a skilled welder. By understanding the unique characteristics and capabilities of each welding technique, you can make an informed decision that best suits your project requirements.
References:
- American Torch Tip. (n.d.). MIG Welding vs. Stick Welding. Retrieved from https://americantorchtip.com/blog/mig-welding-vs-stick-welding/
- Practical Machinist. (2006, January 11). Is stick any stronger than mig? Retrieved from https://www.practicalmachinist.com/forum/threads/is-stick-any-stronger-than-mig.131465/
- WeldingWeb. (2021, March 8). Can you explain why stick welding supposedly gives better penetration than mig? Retrieved from https://weldingweb.com/vbb/threads/679811-Can-you-explain-why-stick-welding-supposedly-gives-better-penetration-than-mig
- TWI Global. (n.d.). What is the Difference Between Stick Welding and MIG? Retrieved from https://www.twi-global.com/technical-knowledge/faqs/mig-vs-stick-welding
- Kevin Caron. (2012, October 24). MIG Welding vs. Arc Welding – Which Welder When? [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iAhNCULPrRE
The techiescience.com Core SME Team is a group of experienced subject matter experts from diverse scientific and technical fields including Physics, Chemistry, Technology,Electronics & Electrical Engineering, Automotive, Mechanical Engineering. Our team collaborates to create high-quality, well-researched articles on a wide range of science and technology topics for the techiescience.com website.
All Our Senior SME are having more than 7 Years of experience in the respective fields . They are either Working Industry Professionals or assocaited With different Universities. Refer Our Authors Page to get to know About our Core SMEs.